PickSmartly Buying Guide

Best Buttonsmith Holders in 2026

9.6 PM Score
Products Compared
28
Brands Ranked
1
Our guides are compiled from product information and customer ratings. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Editor's Choice

Our Top Picks for Buttonsmith Holders

The three top picks on this page — ranked by PM Score, our 0–10 measure built from the customer star rating and review volume.

#1

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Fishing Boat Sidekick Retractable Badge Reel - Extra Heavy Duty - Carabiner and Key Ring - Made in The USA

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Fishing Boat Retractable Badge Reel

BUTTONSMITH SK-VANGOGH-FISHINGBOAT 4.00 X 1.50 X 0.50 Inches 3.00 ounces

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • STYLISH: Carry your ID card key and keys in style with this top-of-the-line super-premium American-made retractable reel.
  • RELIABLE: Guaranteed for a full year, these are built on the Key-Bak Sidekick retractors with the stainless steel springs tested in excess of 1,000,000 pulls.
  • USEFUL: Has a 24" Kevlar cord for quiet extension and added durability, a carabiner clip, a snapping badge loop, and a key ring attachment. Designed to hold 4 oz.
  • MADE IN USA: These badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes

The Buttonsmith Van Gogh Fishing Boat Sidekick is a masterclass in combining fine art with industrial-grade durability. I was immediately struck by how much more substantial this feels compared to the flimsy plastic reels you typically find in office supply aisles. It utilizes a heavy-duty Key-Bak Sidekick retractor, meaning the stainless steel spring is rated for over a million pulls, which is absolute overkill in the best way possible. The 24-inch Kevlar cord provides a silent, rugged extension that handles up to 4 oz of gear without stuttering. Between the carabiner clip, the snapping badge loop, and the integrated key ring, it is a versatile powerhouse for anyone needing to carry IDs and keys simultaneously. Plus, knowing it is made in the USA adds a layer of confidence to its long-term reliability.

What We Like
Million-pull stainless spring
Durable Kevlar cord
American-made quality
Carabiner and key ring
Heavy-duty Sidekick design
#2

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Sunflowers Sidekick Retractable Badge Reel - Extra Heavy Duty - Carabiner And Key Ring - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH SK-VANGOGH-SUNFLOWERS 4.00 X 1.50 X 0.50 Inches 3.00 ounces

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • STYLISH: Carry your ID card key and keys in style with this top-of-the-line super-premium American-made retractable reel.
  • RELIABLE: Guaranteed for a full year, these are built on the Key-Bak Sidekick retractors with the stainless steel springs tested in excess of 1,000,000 pulls.
  • USEFUL: Has a 24" Kevlar cord for quiet extension and added durability, a carabiner clip, a snapping badge loop, and a key ring attachment. Designed to hold 4 oz.
  • MADE IN USA: These badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No
#3

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Mulberry Tree Sidekick Retractable Badge Reel - Extra Heavy Duty - Carabiner And Key Ring - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH SK-VANGOGH-MULBERRYTREE 4.00 X 1.50 X 0.50 Inches 3.00 ounces

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.6 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • STYLISH: Carry your ID card key and keys in style with this top-of-the-line super-premium American-made retractable reel.
  • RELIABLE: Guaranteed for a full year, these are built on the Key-Bak Sidekick retractors with the stainless steel springs tested in excess of 1,000,000 pulls.
  • USEFUL: Has a 24" Kevlar cord for quiet extension and added durability, a carabiner clip, a snapping badge loop, and a key ring attachment. Designed to hold 4 oz.
  • MADE IN USA: These badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#4

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Starry Night Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - with Alligator Clip and Extra-Long 36 inch Standard Duty Cord - Made in The USA

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Starry Night Tinker Reel

BUTTONSMITH TR-VANGOGH-1-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No

Healthcare professionals and office workers tired of clinical, boring accessories need the Buttonsmith Tinker Reel to inject some personality into their daily uniform. I was immediately struck by the patented design that lets you swap out the decorative tops. This set comes with four different designs, including a stunning Van Gogh Starry Night motif, so you can match your mood or outfit effortlessly. Beyond the aesthetics, this isn't a flimsy trinket. It features a heavy-duty 36-inch cord and a stainless alligator clip that feels substantial in hand. Knowing it has been tested for over a million pulls gives me real confidence in its longevity. It is a rare find that balances high-end artistic expression with genuine, American-made durability.

What We Like
Swappable decorative tops
Extra-long 36-inch cord
Stainless alligator clip
Made in USA
Million-pull durability
#5

Buttonsmith Anatomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Belt Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-SCIENCE-ANATOMY-B3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless belt clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#6

Buttonsmith Nurse 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Pin Back And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-NURSE-1-PIN3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless pin back, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#7

Buttonsmith Anatomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-SCIENCE-ANATOMY-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#8

Buttonsmith Nurse 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And 24 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-NURSE-1-A2K 3.00 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a key ring attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#9

Buttonsmith Space Cadet Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-SPACECADET-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#10

Buttonsmith Astronomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-SCIENCE-ASTRONOMY-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#11

Buttonsmith Klimt Kiss Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-KLIMT-THEKISS 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#12

Buttonsmith Puppies Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-PUPPIES 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#13

Buttonsmith Van Gogh Starry Night Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And 24 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-VANGOGH-1-A2K 3.00 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a key ring attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No
#14

Buttonsmith Hokusai Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Belt Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-HOKUSAI-B3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.04 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless belt clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#15

Buttonsmith Hokusai Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-HOKUSAI-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.04 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No
#16

Buttonsmith Tiffany Poppies Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-TIFFANY-2-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.04 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#17

Buttonsmith Morris Blackthorn Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-MORRIS5 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No
#18

Buttonsmith William Morris 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-MORRIS-1-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 0.02 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#19

Buttonsmith Monet Water Lilies Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Belt Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-MONET-1-B3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 0.75 Inches 0.03 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

9.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless belt clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#20

Buttonsmith At The Beach Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-ATTHEBEACH 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

7.4 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#21

Buttonsmith Shape Patterns Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-ART-SHAPEPATTERNS 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

6.5 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#22

Buttonsmith Halloween Icons Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-HALLOWEENDB 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

6.1 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#23

Buttonsmith Sunburst Custom Vinyl Banner 2'x3' - Indoor/Outdoor - Personalize with Your Text - Designed, Printed, and Assembled in USA

Buttonsmith Sunburst Custom Vinyl Banner

BUTTONSMITH BN-2X3-SUNBURST-2LINES 36.00 X 1.20 X 24.00 Inches 1.25 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.9 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • CUSTOM PRINTED IN VIVID FULL-COLOR: Full color digital printing produces vibrant, eye-catching intense color that your customers or audience will notice.
  • DURABLE & WATERPROOF: Your banner will be printed on premium 13 oz indoor/outdoor vinyl which is both waterproof and fade-resistant. You can use them either indoor or outdoor.
  • EYE CATCHING DESIGN: These beautifully designed banners will direct your customer's attention where you need it.
  • FINISHED FOR QUALITY: Your price includes the highest-quality finishing available, with hemmed edges and grommets every 24” along the top and bottom of the banner.
  • DESIGNED, PRINTED, & ASSEMBLED IN THE USA: We design, print, and grommet these banners just for you in the USA.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No

Your storefront needs to grab attention from across the street during a busy weekend rush. The Buttonsmith Sunburst Custom Vinyl Banner delivers exactly that kind of visual punch through its high-intensity, full-color digital printing. I was particularly impressed by the build quality. The 13 oz vinyl feels substantial and handles the elements well thanks to its waterproof and fade-resistant properties. Whether you are hanging this in a brightly lit office or mounting it outdoors, the hemmed edges and grommets placed every 24 inches ensure it stays securely in place without sagging. It is a reliable, American-made solution for anyone needing a professional, personalized way to direct foot traffic or highlight a specific promotion.

What We Like
Vibrant full-color printing
Waterproof 13 oz vinyl
Fade-resistant material
Reinforced hemmed edges
Integrated metal grommets
#24

Buttonsmith Watercolor Custom Vinyl Banner 2'x3' - Indoor/Outdoor - Personalize with Your Text - Designed, Printed, and Assembled in USA

Buttonsmith Custom Watercolor Vinyl Banner

BUTTONSMITH BN-2X3-WATERCOLOR-3LINES 36.00 X 1.20 X 24.00 Inches 1.25 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.9 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • CUSTOM PRINTED IN VIVID FULL-COLOR: Full color digital printing produces vibrant, eye-catching intense color that your customers or audience will notice.
  • DURABLE & WATERPROOF: Your banner will be printed on premium 13 oz indoor/outdoor vinyl which is both waterproof and fade-resistant. You can use them either indoor or outdoor.
  • EYE CATCHING DESIGN: These beautifully designed banners will direct your customer's attention where you need it.
  • FINISHED FOR QUALITY: Your price includes the highest-quality finishing available, with hemmed edges and grommets every 24” along the top and bottom of the banner.
  • DESIGNED, PRINTED, & ASSEMBLED IN THE USA: We design, print, and grommet these banners just for you in the USA.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 No No No

The Buttonsmith Watercolor Custom Vinyl Banner delivers professional-grade visual impact through its stunning, high-intensity digital printing. I was particularly impressed by the vibrancy of the colors, which makes the personalized text pop against the artistic background. Since it is constructed from heavy-duty 13 oz vinyl, it handles both indoor and outdoor environments without losing its edge or fading. The build quality is evident in the reinforced hemmed edges and the strategic placement of grommets every 24 inches, making installation a breeze. Knowing that every piece is designed, printed, and assembled right here in the USA adds a layer of confidence to the craftsmanship. It is a reliable, eye-catching solution for anyone needing to direct attention to a specific event or storefront.

What We Like
Vivid full-color printing
Waterproof 13 oz vinyl
Fade-resistant material
Hemmed edges
Durable metal grommets
#25

Buttonsmith Teachers Stem Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-TEACHERS-STEM 2.50 X 3.00 X 0.25 inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.7 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#26

Buttonsmith Peace Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-PEACE-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 1.50 ounces

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.2 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#27

Buttonsmith Odilon Tinker Top Set - To Use With Tinker Reel® Badge Reel - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TT-ODILON 1.25 X 1.25 X 0.13 Inches 0.01 Pounds

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • REQUIRES YOU HAVE A TINKER REEL BADGE REEL: These are additional tops only and do not come with the badge reel.
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: These Tinker Tops let you switch the top on your Tinker Reel badge reel whenever you feel like it! Easily match your outfit or your mood.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Tops are designed to fit on our Tinker Reel badge reels that have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes
#28

Buttonsmith Mucha Perfecta Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - With Alligator Clip And Extra-Long 36 Inch Standard Duty Cord - Made In The Usa

BUTTONSMITH TR-MUCHA-PERFECTA-A3B 3.50 X 1.25 X 1.00 Inches 1.50 ounces

PM Score for BUTTONSMITH (PM Score)

5.0 PM Score
Buy on Amazon
  • EXPRESS YOUR STYLE: Tinker Reel badge reels let you change the image on your badge reel whenever you feel like it! Each reel set comes with four swappable decorative Tinker Tops for you to easily switch to match your outfit or your mood.
  • DURABLE: Has an extra-long 36" cord, a stainless alligator clip, and a snap badge attachment. Designed to hold 2 oz.
  • GUARANTEED: Tinker Reel badge reels have been tested for more than 1,000,000 pulls and has a full year guarantee.
  • DESIGNED TO MAKE YOU SMILE: Why use a plain badge reel, when you can use a patented Tinker Reel that allows you to change the top with a new design whenever you feel like it.
  • MADE IN USA AND PATENTED: Tinker Reel badge reels are made in the USA for the highest quality and have been patented.
SELLER SELLER SCORE AMAZON FULFILLED PRIME FREE SHIPPING
Buttonsmith Inc 9.89 Yes Yes Yes

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers about Buttonsmith Holders before you buy.

Start with where the holder will live and what it must grip. Desk and bedside holders prioritize a weighted, non-slip base and easy one-hand access. Wall and under-cabinet holders favor adhesive or screw mounting and a low profile. Car holders need a firm clamp or vent grip plus vibration resistance. Match the holding mechanism (spring clamp, magnetic plate, cradle, elastic strap, or slot) to the item's shape and weight, then confirm the mounting surface before buying.

Most spring-clamp and cradle holders are rated for roughly 1–3 lbs and fit items 2.2–4 inches wide, while magnetic mounts depend on the plate and magnet strength rather than size alone. Heavier items such as tablets, tools, or large bottles usually need a screw-fixed or weighted-base design. Always check the listed weight limit and maximum grip width, and leave a 20–30% margin below the stated maximum for a secure hold.

Screws are the most permanent and handle the most weight and heat. Adhesive pads are strong on smooth, clean surfaces but weaken on textured or painted walls. Clamps suit desks, headrests, and vents but depend on the surface thickness. Suction cups work best on glass and smooth tile and need periodic re-seating. For anything over a couple of pounds, or for a location that gets bumped, prefer a mechanical fixing over adhesive alone.

Usually not reliably. Adhesive pads perform best on glass, glazed tile, smooth metal, and sealed laminate. Painted drywall can peel away under load, and brick, fabric, and rough render leave too little contact area. For those surfaces, use a screw-mounted holder or a clamp-style design instead of adhesive.

Wipe the area with isopropyl alcohol and let it dry completely — avoid glass cleaners, which leave a film. Press the holder firmly for 30–60 seconds and then wait the full cure time stated by the maker, often 12–24 hours, before adding weight. Applying it to a cold or humid surface, or loading it immediately, is the most common reason adhesive mounts fail.

It depends on the grip style. Spring clamps and cradles need flat side edges, so bulky wallets, grips, and pop sockets can prevent a firm hold or block wireless charging. Magnetic mounts generally require a metal plate or a magnetic case, and the plate may need to sit outside the case. If you use a thick or grippy case, look for a holder with a wide opening and adjustable arms.

Check that the mounting base is fully tightened and the surface is flat. A slightly proud screw head or curved panel is a common cause of wobble. For articulated arms, tighten the joint screws or the locking collar, and avoid over-extending the arm beyond its rated reach. If the grip has loosened, many spring designs can be re-tensioned or the padding replaced.

Metal arms and brackets, silicone or rubber grip pads, and UV-stable ABS or polycarbonate resist heat and sunlight far better than cheap rigid plastic, which can yellow and become brittle. In bathrooms and kitchens, choose rust-resistant stainless or coated hardware and avoid untreated steel springs. Silicone and TPE pads also grip better than smooth plastic when surfaces are damp.

Remove the holder if possible and wipe it with a damp microfiber cloth and mild soap. Avoid alcohol or solvent cleaners on rubber and silicone pads, since they dry out and harden the surface, which reduces grip. Dust and lint trapped on the pads are the main cause of slipping, so rinse and air-dry them regularly rather than scrubbing.

Confirm the surface is smooth and non-porous, that the holder's temperature range covers a hot car interior, and that the adhesive or suction base is removable without residue. For windshields, check local rules about where a mount may be placed, and prefer a design with a locking lever or twist ring over a plain press-on cup if the item is heavy.
Rankings & Insights

Our Buttonsmith Holders Rankings

28 Products Compared
8.2 Avg PM Score
1 Brands Ranked

Top 10 Buttonsmith Holders Brands on Amazon

Share of top-ranked products by brand, from our rankings.

  1. 01 Buttonsmith 28 (100%)

How We Selected These Products

We compared Buttonsmith Holders products using product details and customer ratings to identify the best options in the cell phone accessories. The top brands in this selection include vanmass, boperzi, lamicall, qifutan, miracase, urbanstrive, wbbog, heagoale and kaistyle and gfware.

From that comparison we shortlisted the top 28 Buttonsmith Holders for this page. The sellers featured here include vanmass store, pranceus, lamicalldirect, lanjinheyus, miracase mount official, urbanstrive direct, wbbogus, heagoale-us and kaistyle mount official and bxkus.

We aim to help you find the right holders products for your needs and save you time when choosing which Buttonsmith Holders to buy.

Side by Side

Comparison Table

Compare the top 28 picks at a glance — select a column to sort.

# Product Brand PM Score Where to Buy
1 Buttonsmith Van Gogh Fishing Boat Retractable Badge Reel Buttonsmith 9.6 Buy on Amazon
2 Buttonsmith Van Gogh Sunflowers Sidekick Retractable Badge R Buttonsmith 9.6 Buy on Amazon
3 Buttonsmith Van Gogh Mulberry Tree Sidekick Retractable Badg Buttonsmith 9.6 Buy on Amazon
4 Buttonsmith Van Gogh Starry Night Tinker Reel Buttonsmith 9.5 Buy on Amazon
5 Buttonsmith Anatomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.5 Buy on Amazon
6 Buttonsmith Nurse 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.5 Buy on Amazon
7 Buttonsmith Anatomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.5 Buy on Amazon
8 Buttonsmith Nurse 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.5 Buy on Amazon
9 Buttonsmith Space Cadet Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
10 Buttonsmith Astronomy Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - w Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
11 Buttonsmith Klimt Kiss Tinker Top Set - to use with Tinker R Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
12 Buttonsmith Puppies Tinker Top Set - to use with Tinker Reel Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
13 Buttonsmith Van Gogh Starry Night Tinker Reel Retractable Ba Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
14 Buttonsmith Hokusai Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
15 Buttonsmith Hokusai Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - wit Buttonsmith 9.4 Buy on Amazon
16 Buttonsmith Tiffany Poppies Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Re Buttonsmith 9.1 Buy on Amazon
17 Buttonsmith Morris Blackthorn Tinker Top Set - to use with T Buttonsmith 9.1 Buy on Amazon
18 Buttonsmith William Morris 1 Tinker Reel Retractable Badge R Buttonsmith 9.1 Buy on Amazon
19 Buttonsmith Monet Water Lilies Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Buttonsmith 9.1 Buy on Amazon
20 Buttonsmith at The Beach Tinker Top Set - to use with Tinker Buttonsmith 7.4 Buy on Amazon
21 Buttonsmith Shape Patterns Tinker Top Set - to use with Tink Buttonsmith 6.5 Buy on Amazon
22 Buttonsmith Halloween Icons Tinker Top Set - to use with Tin Buttonsmith 6.1 Buy on Amazon
23 Buttonsmith Sunburst Custom Vinyl Banner Buttonsmith 5.9 Buy on Amazon
24 Buttonsmith Custom Watercolor Vinyl Banner Buttonsmith 5.9 Buy on Amazon
25 Buttonsmith Teachers STEM Tinker Top Set - to use with Tinke Buttonsmith 5.7 Buy on Amazon
26 Buttonsmith Peace Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Reel - with Buttonsmith 5.2 Buy on Amazon
27 Buttonsmith Odilon Tinker Top Set - to use with Tinker Reel® Buttonsmith 5.0 Buy on Amazon
28 Buttonsmith Mucha Perfecta Tinker Reel Retractable Badge Ree Buttonsmith 5.0 Buy on Amazon